You’re Protesting Wrong

Yesterday I received my first ever anti-semitic tweet sent to me accusing me and someone else of being Zionists strictly because we’re Jewish. It’s quite a milestone for me. Here is something I wrote on the old blog (circa 2014) about this conflation that happens vis a via Jews and Zionism:

Since the start of the Gaza offensive (or war) by Israel, there seems to have been a growing number of anti-semitic incidents. From synagogues being attacked in France to the most recent attack on a student at Temple university (thinking about it I find a degree of irony that this happened at Temple). The majority if not all of these attacks have been in response to Israel entering Gaza. I am not going to discuss if what Israel is doing is justified or not. What I want to talk about is how misguided these protests are.

What do I mean when I say these protests are misguided? Simply put, if you are if you are “protesting” by attacking a synagogue or beating down a local Jew or Israeli, you’re protesting wrong. The proper place to protest is at your local Israeli consulate. Do you know why? That is where the Israeli government is located. An Israeli playing soccer is not a representative of the Israeli government. Additionally it’s OK to block the Brooklyn Bridge and chant “Free Palestine” although I don’t know if you will be convincing anyone who is stuck on the bridge. Oh yeah, getting a permit is highly recommended. Any “protests” that are not at an Israeli government location is nothing more than an assault which should be prosecuted.

Speaking of offences to be prosecuted, I’d like to bring up the thugs who murdered the Arab boy in retaliation for the kidnappings. It is my fervent hope they prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. It seems Israeli law does have the death penalty is specific cases and I an in agreement with Rabbi Levanon that it should be used in this situation.

How to change the primaries for the better

With the primary season about half way through (thankfully) there have been two issues which have bothered me. I believe these three changes would make the primaries more meaningful for those who are running and more importantly for those who are voting.

  1. Closed Primaries – I was amazed to discover how many states didn’t have a true closed primary. Meaning only if you were a registered Democrat or Republican would you be able to vote in the primary. For some reason the state parties (or state governments) believe their primary should be open in some way. This doesn’t work because only the people who have decided to sell identify with a political party should be the ones who decide the fate of the party. There is nothing wrong with considering one’s self independent and not in a party; however if you do then you need to understand you can’t vote in the primaries. I do practice what I’m preaching here. In NYC there is no way to really effect change unless you are a registered Democrat and therefore in spite of my not really having any ideological agreement with the party I am a registered democrat. This also will take care of anyone who just wants to create chaos and vote for the weaker general election candidate.
  2. Early Voting – I am not talking about absentee voting (if you will be away or are in the military). I’m talking about people who are too lazy to go to the polls on Election Day and are able to vote about a month in advance of the state’s primary. This is a silly thing to be because (a) the candidate you voted for might not be in the election any longer (E.G. Marco Rubio) and (b) late breaking news can change the way people think about the existing candidates. If you are voting early you don’t have the benefit of the later information. If we are going to have early voting, maybe the first past the post style needs to be changed to an alternative style

  3. Super or Undeclared Deligates – These deligates are designed to not allow the registered party members their full say in he election. They are allow to vote for who ever they want (usually the front runner) even though the rank and file of the party had other ideas. Not to put too fine a point on it, this is undemocratic and shouldn’t be allowed.
  4. Winner Take All – This is a bonus one because even though I would prefer this style of primary, I see the point a candidate shouldn’t be punished for winning a district but not the entire state. I don’t see a big need to change the way a large number of states award deligate. It’s just a personal preference.

These three changes would make big differences in the how effective primaries are in selecting the candidates for each party. Additionally it would restore fairness to the way primaries are set up.

Welcome to the All New, All Different Blog

Embed from Getty Images

Well folks, due to a massive mess up on my part the old blog got wiped out. I’ll save you the gory details but let’s just say you shouldn’t be working on the security of your blog while you have a migraine. However this is a teachable moment to once again stress how having backups of anything is good. If I had practiced what I preached in regard to my blog, I would still have my old content.

Regardless starting from square one again gives you some opportunities to try different things. One of the things I am trying here is a new name of the blog. After months of focus groups I have finally decided on “Benedict Blog”. My marketing people worked overtime coming up with the name and I think it’s very creative.

I hope you enjoy the ride.

Jews in Comics

Embed from Getty Images

Note: this was originally posted on 2/2/2015. I’ve reposted it on the “new” blog with the original date and edited it for typos.

This morning while I was washing the dishes from Shabbos, I was listening to Giant Size a podcast about comics. It was part two of a series talking about universe wide cross-over events. Moises mentioned something about the Green Lantern comics which caught my ear. DC had a Muslim Green Lantern for a short time. This comment reminded me of something I felt when Marvel announced there would be a Muslim Ms. Marvel.

No, this won’t be a rant about how comic-book publishers shouldn’t publish books with Muslim characters. I don’t care, if they feel it is going to make them more money and get them new, different readers then more power to them. Additionally this isn’t an anti-diversity post. I don’t care publisher have turned Thor into a woman or that Captain America is now an African-American. However, there is a group which hasn’t been represented as much, I think it’s time for there to be a hero who is Jewish and identifies themselves as Jewish.

When I thought about Jews in comics, I come up with three characters who identify as being Jewish; Kitty Pryde, Magneto, and Ragman1. Why these three and not someone like Batwoman? The reason is that those three have identified themselves as being spiritually Jewish, not just having a Jewish last name or being of Jewish descent.

I’m not asking for the character to have their own title or even to be a major part of an existing book (although either would be nice), I think there is room in any of the comic universes to have someone who is Jewish and deals with the issues pertaining to keeping that religion. It’s already being done with Ms. Marvel, why not with another character and another religion?

The irony is that there are so many editors, writers and artist who are Jewish, one would think this could have easily been done already. In the past it could have been difficult2 but in today’s age of diversity, it would be accepted.

Realistically speaking, I don’t expect it to happen because there won’t be the shock factor that past editorial decisions have had3. Because there would be no shock factor there wouldn’t be a bump in sales. Now that I think of it, it would be interesting to see Magneto dealing with some of the things he’s done4 and trying to fit those into the context of Judaism. In case a comic publisher is worried about getting some of the nuances wrong, I happen to know someone who can help.

  1. There may be more but these three seem to be the most prominent. 
  2. Doing something like this when Siegel & Shuster were publishing Superman would have been impossible. 
  3. The above cases of Captain America, Thor, Ms. Marvel and also Northstar being gay come to mind. They all made a splash in the mainstream press. 
  4. All the murders would just be the beginning